Feedback
Providing feedback is a key method to improve performance. Effective feedback systems inform users of their current status and warn about potential issues, but must avoid over-warning that leads to ignoring alerts.
THE IDEA
Give Feedback
An excellent way to help Humans improve their performance is to provide feedback. Well-designed systems tell people when they are doing well and when they are making mistakes.
- An important type of feedback is a warning that things are going wrong or, even more helpful, are about to go wrong. Our laptops warn us to plug in or shut down when the battery is dangerously low. A Tesla will alert a driver on a trip whether there is enough power left in the battery to reach the destination, and if not, it will alter the GPS directions to include a stop at a charging station. Health alerts can tell you all sorts of things, increasingly in real time. But warning systems have to avoid the problem of offering so many warnings that they are ignored. If our computer constantly nags us about whether we are sure we want to open that attachment, we begin to click “yes” without thinking about it. The warnings are thus rendered useless.
- Feedback can be improved in many activities. Consider the simple task of painting a ceiling. This task is more difficult than it might seem because ceilings are usually painted white, and it can be hard to see exactly where you have painted. Later, when the paint dries, the patches of old paint will be annoyingly visible. How to solve this problem? Some helpful person invented a type of ceiling paint that goes on pink when wet but appears white when dry. Unless the painter is so colorblind that she can’t tell the difference between pink and white, this solves the problem.
When to use it
Giving feedback to employees about their work performance through regular reviews and real-time feedback.
Designing user interfaces that provide immediate feedback on user actions, such as form validation or button presses.
Educational tools that give students instant feedback on quizzes and assignments to enhance learning.
Health monitoring apps that alert users to potential issues while avoiding alarm fatigue.
FROM THEORY TO EVERYDAY LIFE
In practice
Laptop Battery Warning
Laptops warn users to plug in or shut down when the battery is dangerously low, providing feedback to avoid data loss.
Tesla Range Alert
The source describes a Tesla routing example: when the estimated battery charge is insufficient for the destination, navigation includes a charging stop. This illustrates feedback tied to a useful next action.
Health Alerts
Health monitoring devices provide real-time feedback about various health metrics, such as heart rate or glucose levels.
Ceiling Paint Feedback
Ceiling paint that appears pink when wet and white when dry gives immediate visual feedback on where paint has been applied, making the task easier.
A MOMENT TO REFLECT
Put it to work.
How can you design a feedback system that provides timely warnings without causing alert fatigue?
In what areas of your life could better feedback improve your performance?
Think of a system that gives too many warnings: how could it be redesigned to be more effective?
CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION
Source texts
- Nudge The Final Edition (Richard H. Thaler Cass R. Sunstein)